Uncertain Terms
A blog and a podcast by Vinay Amin

Medical AI in plain language, with the error bars left in.

Each post takes one decision from inside a chest X-ray model and turns it into the question a hospital, a regulator, or a patient should be asking.

1post
1episode
Every 2 weeksnew writing

The instrument · what "99% accurate" means on your patients

Read the post

Every alarm a screening tool raises is either a real case or a false one. The split depends less on the model than on how rare the disease is among the people screened. Move the sliders.

0.3%of alarms are real cases

Screen 100,000 people at this rate. About 3 have the disease. The tool flags 1,003: 3 real, 1,000 false alarms.

real cases among the flaggedfalse alarms

At this sensitivity it misses almost no one who is sick.

Real cases caught = rate × sensitivity. False alarms = everyone else × (1 − specificity). The share of alarms that are real is the positive predictive value. Rates from CDC (US, 2025) and WHO (global, 2024).

Mission

Uncertain Terms takes the decisions inside medical AI and translates them into questions a hospital administrator, a regulator, a legislator or a patient can ask. It argues that the rules should require a model to say how sure it is and to admit the limits of what it has seen.

Writing

Sources at the bottom of every post; what I'm unsure about in the margin.

All posts

Podcast

Ten to twelve minutes, one voice, one question per episode.

All episodes
  1. 01 The number on the brochure

    A one-page brochure at a conference booth puts ninety-nine percent accurate in the largest type on the page and Vinay works out slowly and out loud why that number is the least useful true thing about the tool.

    Oct 3, 202611 min · audio soon

Why this exists

About

When I first applied one of my models to chest X-rays from a hospital that had never been used in training, the accuracy dropped from above 99% to somewhere in the sixties. There were two columns of data in a spreadsheet. The first column was like something a vendor might put on a brochure. The second column was like a coin that has been slightly tilted.

After this there was a long discussion about which column to use for the paper. Both were true. The 99% was the model on data similar to the data that it had been trained on. The sixties number was the performance of the model on strangers. The conclusion I came to was that a hospital only ever meets strangers.

Contact

Email

vinayamin25@gmail.com

Questions from a hospital, a newsroom, a classroom, or a legislator's office are welcome. If a post gets something wrong, say so; corrections are noted in place with a date.

Guests and press

Guest requests for the podcast (clinicians, regulators, and people who buy these tools for a living) are especially welcome. Episodes are one question long.

Based in Coral Springs, Florida. Research at Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton.